For me the highlight fish was watching Nancy get out of the boat and walk along a shallow sand section (just like flats fishing.) She got within range of a large butterfly cruising the edge, made a beautiful cast about 4-5 feet in-front of the fish with a popper. And the fish pushed a bow wake to the fly and annihilated the popper!
So yes the popper worked... but it was “less” effective than a subsurface fly. Less effective means you might “only” get 3-4 along a section to take a crack at the fly vs 8-10 subsurface, but the excitement and anticipation level is always maxed out with the popper.
Throughout the week, we were averaging 45-50 Peacocks per day. The guides count Peacocks but don’t count other species like cuda, wolf fish, jacunda, or payara!! The slowest day for Nancy was 18 peacocks to the boat for two people. BUT two of the fish were between 10 and 14 pounds.
Listening to the sound of the popper “glug glug glug” then a loud gulping woosh and your fly disappears never gets old!!
Other highlights for me were fishing with John (an extremely well-traveled angler) and Adrian (who Nancy I met and fished with in Australia on our honeymoon 30 years ago!) Their enthusiasm was contagious and the banter and stories were endless!
We did do some blind casting in the larger lagoons to look for trophy-size fished.This type of fishing is not really my jam, however when you see a school of 5-10” long fish “spray” out of the water with two giant V wakes behind chasing or a 4-5 pound butterfly leaping and skipping across the water with a massive bulge of water hot on its tail it does motivate you to make a few more casts!!
The largest fish of the trip for me was an 8kg (17.64lbs) just surpassing my previous PB of 17lbs from years before.